top of page
Search

Most Experienced Hunters Have Had Scary Close Calls with Firearms

Writer: Patrick Durkin
Patrick Durkin
6 minutes ago
5 min read

   A review of Wisconsin’s shooting incidents the past three years shows at least 76% of the 29 hunters who fired shots that struck themselves or others had earned hunter-education certificates.


   In fact, reports kept by the Department of Natural Resources show 75% of such shooters had at least 25 years of in-field experience after completing hunter-education training.


   Why, then, did they ignore basic rules like “Treat every firearm as if it were loaded,” and “Always point the muzzle in a safe direction?”


   Clearly, experience can breed complacency.


Take it from these two hunters — Mike Foy, left, and Patrick Durkin: Most experienced hunters have at least one scary gun-related story. Therefore, treat every gun as if it’s loaded, and always keep it pointed in a safe direction.   — Patrick Durkin photo


  I have a well-known gun-writer buddy who’s also a serious hunter, reloader and gunsmith. When asked why experienced hunters trigger so many shootings, he said: “Every gun guru I know has at least one (pants-filling) scare that haunts them.”


   His tale goes like this: “I once mounted a bolt-action rifle atop my basement workbench to replace the scope. I knew it was unloaded, and squeezed the trigger. Instead of a click, there was a blast. It dazed me. My ears were ringing. I didn’t know where I was or what happened. Then I looked at the wall in front of me. A PVC pipe leading upstairs to the kitchen was shattered, and a cinder block in the basement wall had a crater in it. Obviously, my rifle wasn’t unloaded.”


   Then he replayed how he had unloaded that rifle a few nights earlier after hunting: “It was dark and my headlamp was off. I dropped the rifle’s floor plate to empty its magazine, and worked the bolt to clear the chamber. Plus, it was cold and my hands were numb. Still, I ‘knew’ I caught that final round, even with the four I was holding from the magazine. I didn’t even count the bullets. I just dumped them into my pocket and closed the bolt, just like I’d done hundreds of times before. Why that cartridge didn’t eject that night, I’ll never know. Maybe I short-stroked it. All I know is that I should have double-checked the chamber before closing the bolt and going home.”


   I had a similar “accident” after an all-day deer hunt 30 years ago. I faced away from my truck, pointed the rifle’s muzzle into the forest, worked the bolt. It was dark, and I assumed the final round ejected into the others cupped in my left hand. I then pulled the trigger on the “empty” chamber. The muzzle blast lighted the area and the bullet fired into the trees.


   My rifle was pointed in a safe direction, but I hadn’t treated it as if it were loaded.


   To further test my friend’s belief that all experienced hunters have scary stories to share, I asked around. I soon had too many tales to share in one book, let alone one newspaper column. Most involve exposed-hammer firearms in which the “safety” is an uncocked hammer, such as on older Winchester 94 rifles and break-open single-shot shotguns.


   Brenda Maier of Clam Lake recalls hunting rabbits with her grandfather and two beagles when she was 12. As the beagles’ barking grew louder, she faced an opening where she expected the bunny to cross. She raised her .410 shotgun and cocked its hammer, but the rabbit ran past her grandfather instead of her, and he rolled it.


   As she approached, she asked, “Did you get it?” When he pointed to the rabbit and started replying, Maier’s gun fired.


   “I still have no idea how it went off,” she said. “All I know is that I’d left the hammer cocked. I’m grateful it was pointed at the ground. A cold, sick feeling washed over me. As I raised my eyes from the ugly spot in the ground a few feet away, I met his eyes. I didn’t see anger or fear; just a long, serious stare. He said, ‘You could’ve blown my leg off.’ I’ll never forget those words.”


   Steve Meurett of Neillsville recalls his father loading a Model 94 Winchester for him near Hazelhurst during his second or third deer-season opener in 1974. “He loaded five cartridges into its tube magazine and then one into the chamber,” Meurett said. “Instead of the hammer easing down safely, it slipped and came down hard, discharging a round into the ground. For 51 years, whenever I hear a random shot at 6:15 a.m. in the pitch dark, I wonder if someone was loading a Winchester Model 94.”


   Other discharges involve older Model 700 Remington bolt-action rifles, which required hunters to flick the two-position safety to “Fire” when unloading. A design flaw sometimes caused these rifles to discharge when hunters released the safety.


   Charlie Klassa of Berlin witnessed it himself. “When shooting time ended, my dad pointed his .30-06 in a safe direction and started to unload when it went off,” he said. “It scared the hell out of both of us. I’ll never forget it. My ears rang all the way home.”


   The same thing happened to Mike Foy of Madison, while unloading his Model 700 BDL. “My friend and I were taking a break to warm up inside, and I was unloading my .270,” Foy wrote. “When I took the safety off, the rifle discharged. I had it pointed up and away from us and the building, and I don’t remember touching the trigger in any way.”


   Remington replaced the safety on Foy’s rifle soon after so he could unload it in the “Safe” position. Still, Foy can’t forget the incident. “I still tense up whenever I unload that rifle,” he said.


   Safeties can also disengage when catching a branch, or a backpack’s strap or frame. My buddy Rich Stedman at the Old T hunting shack in Ashland County is still haunted by an incident from four decades ago.


   “I was 21 or so, and it was my second or third year hunting (with Tom Heberlein),” Stedman said. “We often cut a Christmas tree before heading home, and I spotted one that would please him. I cut it down, slung my rifle over my shoulder, and started dragging. While pulling it through a patch of brush, my gun went off. The muzzle was straight up, but not far above my head.


   “I knew the captain (Heberlein) was at the shack and had to have heard it. I also knew he’d be mad, and think I was careless and wouldn’t invite me back. When I dragged the tree into the yard and went inside, he asked, ‘Did you get him?’ I tried to sound casual when I answered. I told him I had shot at a pinecone to see if my rifle was shooting straight. I never told him the story of what actually happened.”


   As penance for that lie, Stedman tells it now in hopes it will remind others to treat every gun as if it’s loaded.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


2018 Patrick Durkin Outdoors

Created on Wix

bottom of page