top of page
  • Writer's picturePatrick Durkin

Contrasting Styles: 2 Hunters Share Public Land Differently

SODA SPRINGS, Idaho – After bowhunting elk in Idaho’s Caribou-Targhee National Forest for 13 years, I often felt spoiled when realizing I hadn’t encountered another hunter from 2013 through 2017 on these vast public mountains.

Perhaps befitting “lucky 13” superstitions, that streak ended with a clout seven days into my 2018 hunt. After that solitary first week, I had six hunter-on-hunter encounters the next four days, doubling my total from 2006 through 2012. Stranger yet, one individual accounted for three of this year’s interruptions.

When the guy stumbled into my setup near an elk wallow Sept. 17, he was close enough to talk. In the previous two encounters, my waves from across small meadows made him veer off. As he approached my hiding spot with neither awareness of me nor pretense of stealth for our third encounter, I considered my greeting.

Should I channel Will Geer, the actor who played a grizzly hunter/trapper in the 1972 movie “Jeremiah Johnson,” starring Robert Redford? When Redford’s character accidentally intrudes on the old hunter’s setup, the frustrated hunter/trapper yells: “You’re the same dumb pilgrim that I been hearin’ for 20 days, and smellin’ for three! I am Bear Claw Chris Lapp; bloodkin to the grizzer that bit Jim Bridger’s a- -. YOU are molesting my hunt!”

Instead, though, I waited till he was within 20 yards and said, “You sure do get around.”

He looked startled, and then asked, “Is there a wallow over there?” He pointed toward the mudpuddle of an elk wallow I was watching. Brush screened it from his view. I confirmed it was 25 yards ahead. He said he’d been scouting this area “all summer,” and understood this is public land. He also assured me he was as “disappointed” about these encounters as I was.

“I understand,” I replied. “Stuff happens.”

He then moved on, saying he would head over the mountaintop.

I doubted he was all that “disappointed.” My friends and I set up camp Sept. 7, and “our man” and two companions arrived at dawn eight days later. The threesome then parked their boat beside ours, walked through our camp 100 yards up the creek bed, and continued up the valley beyond.

My buddy Mark Endris, who sleeps till dawn before fishing trout, didn’t look out of our tent as the boots crunched past at first light. He assumed I had started late for some reason.

About two hours later, two of them reached the mountaintop meadow I’d been watching since dawn. I pegged them as inexperienced hunters. Rather than sneak to the meadow’s edge and screen themselves in brush to “glass” with binoculars for elk, they simply strode into the opening before pausing to look.

I waved from about 150 yards away. After spotting me, they discussed things and departed up the opposite ridge into the forest. Seconds later, as if knowing I was wondering where these guys came from, Endris text-messaged me to say a boat was parked beside ours, and hunters might be heading my way.

About an hour later the third hunter appeared where the previous two departed. He either didn’t see me waving or ignored me as he walked downhill, descending the route his companions had ascended.

The man’s companions hunted elsewhere after that encounter, but “our man” continued parking beside our boats and walking through our camp each morning. He persisted even though he encountered me or my buddy Chris White six times over four days in or near the highland meadow 1.5 miles northwest and 1,300 feet above camp.

Therefore, I doubt his disappointment rivaled ours. He had broken no laws, of course. These are public lands and no one can command him: “This spot’s taken. You’ll find plenty of great elk the next creek down. Go explore it.”

At least that’s what we did five years before. From 2006 through 2012 we camped and hunted two miles downriver from our current site. But when we arrived in 2013, other hunters were camped in “our spot,” so we continued upriver 2 miles, even though we had seven two-week hunts of knowledge invested in our original site.

We just don’t think it’s cool to park beside another man’s boat, traipse through his campsite, and risk “molesting” his hunt.

Do most public-land hunters agree? Well, “Dreadlocks Dave” does. Here’s that story:

The night before “our man” entered our elk-camp’s infamy, I heard twigs breaking and leaves rustling as something approached my setup above the mountaintop meadow.

A bowhunter sneaked out of the pines and laurel brush minutes later, dreadlocks bunched and bristling atop his head and between his neck and backpack. I whistled and waved. He looked around, spotted me, waved back and approached. We exchanged names, embarrassed smiles, and guarded scouting reports about nearby bulls.

The young man then asked how long I planned to bowhunt the area. When I said we’d finish Sept. 21, he replied, “Well, I’ll stay out of here until you’re gone.” I thanked him for the courtesy, and he continued up the mountain.

We didn’t see him again. I like to think the hunting gods helped Dreadlocks Dave arrow a bull the next day. Those things happen. In 1989, for example, Endris and I spent an autumn afternoon building a ground blind in the Ottawa National Forest in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula. The site was a mile from camp, and required careful navigation in the dark, given that handheld GPS units weren’t yet available.

I arrived a half-hour before shooting light on opening day. Ninety minutes later, a hunter walked past 50 yards away, strode with purpose toward a big cedar, and plunked down like he’d been there often.

I startled him when approaching to ask if that was his traditional stand. He said it was, so I packed up and retreated to a stand nearer camp. Two hours later I shot an 8-point buck as it trailed an estrous doe that passed a minute earlier.

Such experiences make me think fate rewards folks like Dreadlocks Dave. And something tells me he’s a happier person than “our man” will ever be.

‘Dreadlocks Dave’ Burgess, second from left, met Pat Durkin by accident in September 2018 while bowhunting elk in Idaho. He quickly became part of Durkin's elk-camp lore, and visited the camp in September 2019.

63 views0 comments


bottom of page